The dispute is ready to file. You have the contract, the invoices, the emails, and a clear account of what went wrong. Then your lawyer turns to page eleven and reads a paragraph you never looked at closely: any dispute arising out of or relating to the agreement shall be resolved by binding arbitration under the rules of a named arbitration association, in Miami-Dade County.
That paragraph changes the forum, the procedure, the cost structure, and the possibility of appeal. Whether that helps or hurts depends on the dispute and on which side you are on. Either way, it should be understood before anyone files anything, because the first steps taken can determine whether the clause is enforced or lost.
Will a Florida court enforce the clause?
Usually. Both federal law, which governs contracts involving interstate commerce, and the Revised Florida Arbitration Code favor enforcing arbitration agreements according to their terms. When one party files in court and the other moves to compel arbitration, Florida courts ask three questions: whether a valid written agreement to arbitrate exists, whether an arbitrable issue exists, and whether the right to arbitrate was waived. Ordinary contract defenses, such as fraud in the making of the arbitration clause itself or unconscionability, can defeat it, but the burden is on the party resisting, and general complaints about the fairness of arbitration rarely succeed. A claim that the whole contract was induced by fraud usually goes to the arbitrator; only a challenge aimed at the arbitration clause specifically stays with the court. The scope of the clause also matters. Language covering disputes arising out of or relating to the agreement is read broadly and can reach fraud and other tort claims connected to the deal, while narrower language may leave some claims in court.
Who decides whether the dispute belongs in arbitration?
Sometimes the arbitrator. Questions about whether a particular claim falls within the clause are ordinarily for the court, unless the parties clearly and unmistakably delegated them to the arbitrator. The Florida Supreme Court has held that incorporating the rules of the American Arbitration Association, which give arbitrators power to rule on their own jurisdiction, is that kind of clear and unmistakable delegation. In practice this means a party that thinks its claim falls outside the clause may have to make that argument to the arbitrator, not to a judge. Reading which rules the clause adopts is therefore one of the first tasks.
Can the right to arbitrate be lost?
Yes. A party that acts inconsistently with the right to arbitrate, for example by filing a lawsuit on the claims, litigating them, or taking substantial discovery in court before asking for arbitration, can be found to have waived it. Florida courts do not require the other side to show it was prejudiced by the delay, and since 2022 federal courts applying the Federal Arbitration Act take the same approach. A party that wants arbitration should raise it at the very start. A party that prefers court should consider whether the other side's conduct has already waived the clause.
How is arbitration different from a lawsuit?
The decision maker is an arbitrator, or a panel, often chosen for experience in the industry. Discovery is usually narrower and faster, which can lower cost and shorten the timeline. The rules of evidence are applied more loosely. The parties pay the arbitrator's fees and the administrative fees, which can be substantial and are often split, while a court costs the parties little beyond filing fees. Hearings are private, though arbitration is not automatically confidential unless the agreement or the rules make it so. Many clauses still allow a party to go to court for emergency relief, such as an injunction, while the arbitration proceeds.
Can an arbitration award be appealed?
Only in narrow ways. A court will confirm an award unless a party shows one of the limited statutory grounds to vacate it, such as an award procured by corruption, fraud, or other undue means; evident partiality or misconduct by a neutral arbitrator; an arbitrator's refusal to hear material evidence that substantially prejudiced a party; an arbitrator exceeding his or her powers; or the absence of an agreement to arbitrate. Legal or factual errors by the arbitrator generally are not grounds. Under Florida's code, a motion to vacate must be filed within 90 days after the party receives notice of the award; under federal law, the period is three months. Missing that deadline usually ends the challenge.
Is arbitration good or bad for a business?
It depends on the case. Arbitration can favor a party that wants a decision maker who understands the industry, a faster resolution, privacy, and finality. It can disadvantage a party with a strong claim that would benefit from broad discovery, a jury, or the right to appeal an adverse ruling, or one with limited funds to pay a share of the arbitrator's fees. Businesses drafting contracts should decide deliberately whether to include a clause, which rules to use, where hearings will take place, and whether claims for unpaid invoices should be carved out and left for court.
What should you do when a dispute involves an arbitration clause?
Read the clause, the rules it incorporates, and any notice or mediation steps it requires before arbitration can begin. Do not file in court, or respond to a court filing, without first deciding whether to invoke or contest arbitration. Calendar the deadlines in the rules. Consider the arbitrator selection process early, since the choice of arbitrator shapes the case, and research the candidates' backgrounds and prior awards where the rules allow. If the other side files in court despite the clause, a motion to compel arbitration and stay the case should be the first response, filed before engaging on the merits. Preserve the evidence as you would for trial, because the hearing will rely on it just as heavily.
Salomon Smith PLLC represents businesses in commercial disputes across South Florida, in court and in arbitration, including motions to compel arbitration and proceedings to confirm or vacate awards. If your dispute is headed to arbitration, call (305) 297-1018 for a free consultation, or learn more about our business litigation practice.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice.