A Commercial Tenant Abandoned the Space Mid-Lease: A Florida Landlord's Options

An empty retail space seen through its storefront glass, with fixture outlines on the floor and a red stepladder in the middle, illustrating a Florida landlord's options when a commercial tenant abandons the space mid-lease.

The rent check for the first of the month never came. By the tenth, the storefront was dark, the signage was gone, and a moving truck had cleared out everything except the build-out you paid for. The lease has four years left on it. The tenant's owner is not answering calls, and a broker has already asked whether the space is available.

What the landlord does in the next few weeks determines what it can recover for those four years. Florida law gives a commercial landlord a set of choices when a tenant abandons, and they are not interchangeable. Choosing one can close off the others, and the lease itself may expand or limit all of them.

What options does Florida law give the landlord?

Florida courts have long recognized three paths when a commercial tenant abandons before the lease ends. The landlord can treat the lease as terminated and retake the premises for its own account, which ends the tenant's obligation for future rent unless the lease says otherwise. The landlord can retake possession for the tenant's account, relet the space, and hold the tenant liable for the difference between the lease rent and what the new tenant pays, plus the costs of reletting. Or the landlord can leave the lease in place, let the premises sit, and sue for each installment of rent as it comes due. Each has consequences, and the landlord's words and conduct after the abandonment are what a court will read to decide which one was chosen. A letter announcing that the lease is terminated, a new lease signed for the landlord's own benefit, or a long period of silence can each be treated as a choice. The lease itself frequently adds remedies of its own and sets out the notice the landlord must give first, so the default and remedies sections should be read before any letter goes out.

Can the landlord demand all the remaining rent at once?

Only if the lease allows it. An acceleration clause, which makes the entire remaining rent due upon default, is common in Florida commercial leases and is generally enforced when it is clearly written. Courts look closely at how acceleration interacts with reletting, because a landlord cannot collect the full remaining rent from the old tenant and also keep the rent from a new one for the same period. Many leases address this directly with a credit for reletting proceeds. The timing of the demand also matters, because accelerated rent is often negotiated down in exchange for a prompt lump sum, particularly where the tenant or guarantor has assets but would rather not litigate. Where the lease has no acceleration clause, the landlord is limited to rent as it comes due or to damages measured under the option it chose.

Does the landlord have to find a new tenant?

That depends on the option and the lease. Florida courts have generally not required a commercial landlord who keeps the lease in force and sues for rent as it comes due to search for a replacement tenant first, which distinguishes commercial leases from the residential rules. A landlord that retakes for the tenant's account, by contrast, is expected to relet on reasonable terms, because the tenant's liability is measured by what reletting produces. As a practical matter, most landlords want the space occupied, and a reasonable effort to relet also tends to make the damages claim more credible.

What about the property the tenant left behind?

Florida gives landlords a statutory lien for rent on the tenant's property kept on the premises, enforced through a court action called distress for rent. The lien can reach equipment, inventory, and fixtures the tenant left, subject to the rights of lenders whose liens came first. Disposing of a tenant's property without following the law can create liability, so property should be inventoried, photographed, and secured before anything is moved. A landlord who simply wants possession back, when the tenant has not clearly surrendered it, can use Florida's summary procedure for removing a commercial tenant.

Who else can be held liable?

Often the most valuable defendant is not the tenant company. Personal guaranties signed by the owners are common in commercial leases, and a guaranty of the lease generally covers the rent and charges the lease imposes, according to its terms. Some guaranties are limited to a set number of months of rent, or end if the tenant gives notice and surrenders the space in good condition, sometimes called a good guy guaranty. The security deposit and any letter of credit can be applied against the default as the lease allows. If the tenant assigned the lease or sublet, the original tenant usually remains liable unless the landlord released it.

What can the landlord recover besides rent?

Commercial leases typically shift a range of other charges to the tenant: common area maintenance, taxes, insurance, late fees, interest, and the costs of reletting, including brokerage commissions and reasonable improvements needed to prepare the space for a new tenant. Damage to the premises beyond normal wear is recoverable. Most commercial leases also include a prevailing party attorney's fee clause, which changes the economics of pursuing a tenant or guarantor with assets. Unamortized tenant improvement allowances and abated rent are sometimes recoverable when the lease makes them conditional on full performance.

What should a landlord do after discovering an abandonment?

Document the condition of the premises and anything left behind. Secure the space, but check the lease before changing locks or declaring the lease terminated, since those acts may signal a choice among the options. Send written notice of default in the form the lease requires. Pull the guaranty, the security deposit and any letter of credit, and the tenant's payment history. Decide on a strategy before speaking with a new tenant, so that reletting is done in a way that preserves the claim against the old one.

 

Salomon Smith PLLC represents commercial landlords and tenants in lease disputes across South Florida, focusing on substantial commercial matters. If a tenant has walked away from a lease with years remaining, call (305) 297-1018 for a free consultation, or learn more about our breach of contract practice.

 

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice.

Previous
Previous

When the Landlord Breaches a Commercial Lease in Florida: A Tenant's Claims and Remedies

Next
Next

A Customer That Owes You Filed for Bankruptcy: What a Florida Business Can Still Do