The roof leaked through the summer, and the landlord's property manager kept promising a contractor. Then the landlord began construction next door that blocked the parking lot for three months, and the annual reconciliation of shared expenses arrived with a bill twice the size of last year's. Your business has lost customers, and your lease has six years left. Withholding rent until the landlord fixes things feels like the obvious move.
It is often the most dangerous one. Florida law gives commercial tenants real claims against a landlord that breaches, but the rules are different from residential leases, and a tenant who stops paying can lose its defenses and its space before the landlord's breach is ever heard.
What does a commercial landlord owe the tenant?
Mostly what the lease says. Florida's residential protections, including the statutory duty to maintain the premises, do not apply to commercial leases, and courts generally do not imply a warranty that commercial space is fit for the tenant's purpose. The landlord's duties come from the lease: structural and roof repairs, building systems, common areas, parking, access, signage, exclusive use protections, and the services the lease promises. One duty is implied in every lease, the covenant of quiet enjoyment, which protects the tenant's possession and use against substantial interference by the landlord or those acting for it. Beyond that, the allocation of responsibility varies widely. A gross lease may leave most repairs with the landlord, while a triple net lease may shift nearly everything, including the roof and structure, to the tenant. Reading the lease's repair, maintenance, and casualty sections side by side is the first step in any dispute, because the same leaking roof can be the landlord's breach under one lease and the tenant's problem under another.
Can a tenant stop paying rent when the landlord breaches?
Generally not, unless the lease expressly allows it. In most commercial leases, a tenant's obligation to pay rent is treated as independent of the landlord's obligations, so the landlord's failure to repair does not by itself excuse rent. And there is a procedural trap. When a landlord sues for possession, Florida law requires the tenant to pay the rent alleged to be due into the court registry, and to keep paying rent as it comes due while the case is pending. A tenant that fails to make those deposits is deemed to have waived its defenses other than payment, and the landlord can obtain possession without a hearing on the merits. A tenant with a genuine grievance should keep paying, under a written reservation of rights, and pursue its claims directly.
What is constructive eviction?
It is the doctrine that applies when the landlord's breach makes the premises unusable for their intended purpose, such as a failure to repair that leaves the space unfit or interference that blocks access. A tenant that proves constructive eviction can be released from future rent. The catch is that the tenant must actually leave, within a reasonable time after the conditions arise. A tenant that stays in possession while claiming constructive eviction usually loses the argument. Because leaving is a serious step with the risk of being wrong, it should be taken only after notice to the landlord and a careful assessment of the evidence.
Can a tenant challenge common area charges?
Yes, and these disputes are among the most frequent. Most commercial leases pass through a share of operating expenses, taxes, and insurance, with an annual reconciliation. The lease defines what may be included, how the tenant's share is calculated, whether there are caps on increases, and what is excluded, such as capital improvements, the landlord's own overhead, or costs that belong to other tenants' spaces. Many leases give the tenant a right to audit the landlord's records within a set period after the statement. That period is often short, and a tenant that misses it may lose the right to object, so reconciliations should be reviewed when they arrive.
What can a tenant recover?
Depending on the breach and the lease: the cost of repairs the landlord was obligated to make, abatement of rent where the lease provides it, overcharges, and damages for losses caused by the breach, including lost profits when they can be proven with reasonable certainty and are not barred by the lease. Many commercial leases include clauses waiving consequential damages or limiting the landlord's liability to its interest in the building, and those clauses are read closely. In serious cases, a court can enforce the landlord's obligations directly, for example by ordering it to stop interfering with access. Most commercial leases award attorney's fees to the prevailing party.
What if the landlord violates an exclusive use or signage right?
These rights are often worth more to a retail tenant than any repair obligation. An exclusive use clause, which bars the landlord from leasing to a competing business in the same center, is enforceable according to its terms, and a breach can support damages, rent reduction under the lease, or an injunction against the competing lease. Signage, visibility, and parking rights work the same way. Read the clause, the remedies it lists, and any conditions attached, such as the tenant remaining open and in good standing. A tenant that discovers a competing lease should act quickly, because an injunction is far easier to obtain before the competitor opens its doors than after.
What should a tenant do when problems start?
Give written notice in the form and to the address the lease requires; many claims fail because the landlord was never put on proper notice. Photograph conditions and keep records of lost business and expenses. Keep paying rent unless the lease clearly allows otherwise, and say in writing that payment is made under protest. Calendar audit and objection deadlines. If the lease requires mediation or a specific dispute procedure, follow it. Then evaluate the claim before the next renewal or the landlord's next demand.
Salomon Smith PLLC represents commercial tenants and landlords in lease disputes across South Florida, focusing on substantial commercial matters. If your landlord's breach is costing your business, call (305) 297-1018 for a free consultation, or learn more about our breach of contract practice.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice.