The money went out in pieces over two years. A wire for the down payment on a condo he said would be in both your names. Transfers for his business when a client paid late. A check to clear a tax bill. Each time there was a conversation about paying it back, and for a while there were payments. Then the relationship ended, the payments stopped, and the message you finally received said that everything you gave him was a gift.
Loans between people who trust each other are rarely written down, which is exactly why they end up in court. Florida law gives the person who lent the money several ways to recover it. Which one works depends on what the paper trail shows, how the money moved, and how quickly the lender acts.
Is it a loan or a gift?
That is the central question, and the person who calls it a gift usually raises it first. A gift under Florida law requires the giver's intent to make a present gift, delivery, and acceptance, and the person claiming a gift generally carries the burden of proving that intent. A loan requires an agreement that the money would be repaid. Courts look at everything around the transfer: what was said and written at the time, whether any repayments were made, whether the amounts match a specific need the borrower described, and whether the parties treated the money as owed afterward. A relationship does not turn a loan into a gift. Neither does the absence of a signed note. But close relationships make the gift argument more plausible, so the evidence matters more.
What counts as proof of a loan without a promissory note?
More than most lenders expect. Text messages and emails in which the borrower thanks you for the loan, promises to pay it back, or proposes a schedule. Memo lines on checks and on payment app transfers that say "loan" or "for the car, will repay." Partial repayments, which are hard to reconcile with a gift. Bank records showing the money went where the borrower said it was needed. Witnesses who heard the borrower describe the arrangement. Even a later message disputing the amount, but not the debt itself, helps. Gather all of it before you send a demand, because once the borrower understands a lawsuit is coming, the tone of the messages changes.
Does it matter whether anything was written down?
It changes the deadline and sometimes the proof, but rarely the right to recover. Florida allows five years to sue on a written contract and four years on an oral one. A signed promissory note is the clearest case. A string of messages that states the amount and the promise to repay may qualify as a written agreement, or may not, depending on what the messages actually say. A note payable on demand has its own timing rules under Florida's commercial code, one more reason to look at the documents before assuming a deadline. Where an agreement cannot be proven at all, a claim for unjust enrichment can still reach money the borrower received and kept under circumstances that make keeping it unfair.
What if the money went into the borrower's business or property?
Then the claim may reach further than the borrower personally. Money lent to an individual and used to fund that person's company is still owed by the individual, but if the company received the funds directly, it may owe them too. If your money paid for real estate titled in the borrower's name, Florida courts can impose an equitable lien or a constructive trust on the property in the right circumstances, particularly where the borrower obtained the money through false promises. That can matter a great deal when the borrower has few other assets. Tracing is the work here: following each transfer from your account to where it ended up, using bank statements and, where needed, subpoenas to the receiving banks.
Can the claim include fraud?
Sometimes. A loan that simply went unpaid is a contract claim. A loan obtained through statements the borrower knew were false when made, such as a business that did not exist, an emergency that never happened, or a promise of repayment never intended, can support a fraud claim as well, with different remedies and, in egregious cases, the possibility of punitive damages with the court's permission. Fraud must be pleaded with specifics and proven, and courts are wary of relabeling every broken promise as fraud. But where the facts support it, the claim changes the leverage. Fraud claims in Florida generally carry a four-year period, counted under special rules from when the fraud was or should have been discovered.
What if the relationship was a marriage?
Then the answer may run through family court instead. Money exchanged between spouses is usually sorted out as part of dividing property in a divorce. For unmarried partners, friends, relatives, and business associates, the claim belongs in civil court, and the length or seriousness of the relationship does not change that. Agreements made in writing between partners, including written acknowledgments of a debt, are enforced like any other contract, and an acknowledgment signed after the fact can be among the strongest evidence a lender has.
What should you do before demanding repayment?
Collect and organize the record: every transfer with its date, amount, account, and memo; every message about the money; any repayments. Build a running total, with the repayments credited. Do not delete anything or let a phone backup lapse. Avoid angry messages that could be read as admitting the money was a gift, and avoid threats. A written demand from a lawyer that sets out the amount and the evidence often produces a payment plan or a negotiated settlement. When it does not, a lawsuit is the next step, and in the right case, a request to freeze assets before judgment can follow.
Salomon Smith PLLC represents individuals and businesses recovering loans and other money owed across South Florida, including loans made between partners, relatives, and friends. If someone is calling your loan a gift, call (305) 297-1018 for a free consultation, or learn more about our collections practice.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice.